Finding Wilderness

Archive for the ‘Attack Avoidance’ Category

There was a a previous cougar attack in British Columbia on December 31st, this one in Danskin. Two cougars attacked two young children playing outside while there mother was cleaning a church. The mother rushed out, saw that one of the cougars had the head of her seven-year-old boy in its mouth. She hit it on the head with a rag and it ran away. Her five-year-old daughter said that there was also another cougar. The family appears lucky. Attacking cougars are usually more persistent than this.

A golden retriever defended an 11-year-old boy when he was attacked by a cougar in his backyard in Boston Bar, British Columbia. The dog rushed to intervene as the cougar was going for the boy. While the cougar turned its attack on the dog, the boy ran into the house and the family called 911. The dog undoubtedly saved the boy from serious injury, if not his life. What is amazing to me is that the police were able to arrive soon enough to shoot the cougar and save the dog. (Arrived within one minute according to the CTV News report.)

There are a few cases where people have successfully fought off an attacking mountain lion with a pocket knife.  The victims usually end up on the ground with animal, and the cats are relentless until killed or severely injured.  I just came across this attack from 2007 in California.  A 65 year-old women used a ballpoint pen to fight back against a mountain lion that was attacking her 70-year old husband.  Here is the pertinent part of the story as reported by Paul Bright of Associated Content.

Jim Hamm of Fortuna, CA, and his wife, Nell, were enjoying a hike at the Prairie Creek Redwoods State Park near the California north coast when a female mountain lion suddenly pounced on him. His wife, walking ahead of him was unaware of the attack at first until she heard him call for help. Nell Hamm quickly attacked the lion with whatever she could get her hands on as Jim’s head was in the lion’s mouth.

Nell first grabbed a branch and began to beat the mountain lion, but it wouldn’t let Jim go. Jim told her, “I’ve got a pen in my pocket and get the pen and jab him in the eye,’” she said. “So I got the pen and tried to put it in his eye, but it didn’t want to go in as easy as I thought it would.” When the pen failed to work, Nell picked up the log and began to beat the lion again. The mountain lion released its grip, stared at Nell, and slowly walked away as she screamed at it.

A few interesting reports about mountain lions this week:

As reported by KUSA TV, in Colorado, a 12 year old snapped two photos of a mountain lion with his cell phone camera from his car in a suburban neighborhood near Denver.

A female mountain lion was killed in Iowa County.  One of the residents had been saying for years that he had seen a mountain lion, but no one believed him.

But the top story is this man, who defended himself last July (2009) with a chainsaw when a mountain lion rushed at him while he was sawing wood near Grand Teton National Park. His young child had been with him just a few minutes before the attack.

Just came across this post that provides yet another example of the limitation of guns in general and handguns in particular to stop aggressive animals:

My friend I hate to be the one to pass along bad
news; but NO handgun caliber is adequate
for one shot stops on the big bears or mountain
lions. Recently, a friend was hunting in the
Oregon forest and came upon an angry cougar.
The cougar took six shot’s of .357 magnum’s to
his mid section, and was still able to launch some
what of an attack! I’m not sure what load he was
using; but I believe the gun was a Smith & Wesson
627PC model?

Best advice I could give, would be to carry the largest
caliber that you can control; and place your shot’s
to a vital area. Caliber’s that come to mind, would
be not smaller than the .44 Remington magnum;
up to and including the .480 Ruger. Most satisfying
probably would be the .45 LC using heavy handloads.

I agree with the author’s conclusions, except that I would recommend using pepper spray before resorting to a gun. In most cases you can change an animal’s mind with pepper spray quicker than you can kill it with a bullet.  True you can kill an animal instantly if you hit it in the brain, but that is hard to do.  It takes an animal awhile to die, even if you hit it in the heart or lungs.

Here is an account where pepper was used effectively to deter a mountain lion.

As I make clear at my page on “fighting bears,” I think a large bore handgun is the best backup to pepperspray, but shouldn’t be your first defense.

While we are on the subject of animal territories, here is an interesting report on great white shark territories that indicates they wander less than was thought, staying close to shore and near areas where humans hang out, but also having predictable migration patterns between California and Hawaii.

Bonnie Berkowitz, Gene Thorp and Todd Lindeman/The Washington Post

I have to say though, shark biologists have the same tendency to minimize the reality of shark attack risk in the same way that wildlife researchers do with bears, cougars and other dangerous predators.  This quote from the Washington Post Article:

The fact that “a major concentration” of great whites can ignore the humans who might have crossed their path there “shows us the sharks are really minding their own business. The number of interactions with people is very small, considering,” said Stanford University post-doctoral scholar Salvador J. Jorgensen, the paper’s lead writer.

If I ever have a chance to have a conversation with Mr. Jorgensen, I will point out that what matters to humans is not the number of sharks that could have bit them, but the number that actually do.  Likewise, a person being attacked by a shark doesn’t care what a shark’s regular business is, only what it is doing right then at the time of the attack.  If humans are successful in making the oceans more healthy for sharks, and thereby increasing their populations, that is a good thing in my view.  But we should face the increased risk to humans squarely.

Eastern Coyote (Canis latrans) Photo by Steve Byland

“Biologists baffled by attack” is the headline from the Chronicle Herald article by Ian Fairclough and Evan Hoare, a Nova Scotia newspaper.  The article quotes Jon Way, said to have studied coyotes for 12 years, and who runs Eastern Coyote Research in Massachusetts:

“I don’t think they regard people, even kids, as an opportunity for a food source, so this is certainly an abnormal attack,” Mr. Way said. “They certainly are not like (big) cats that regard people as food, they just don’t do that.”

I am always baffled at biologists who are baffled when larger predators attack and even kill people.  Mr. Way should know that at least one child has been killed by a coyotes, and there have been numerous attacks by coyotes on children as well as adults (including an attack on two boys right here in Bellevue in 2006).

One of the reasons I started BEARS and Other Top Predators magazine 11 years ago was that I didn’t trust the information about animal attacks that I was getting from people who should know better — from public land managers and publicly funded wildlife biologists.   For example, when we first started the magazine, many park rangers and even wildlife PhDs told us that there has never been a documented fatal killing of a human by a wolf.  It was repeated like a mantra.  This didn’t ring true, especially since it is common knowledge that dogs sometimes kill humans.  As it turned out, there are numerous documented cases of wolves preying on humans, including some in North America in the last two decades.

Coyotes are no different from other predators, except the are smaller than wolves, bears and cougars.   The only reason fatal attacks by coyotes on humans is more rare than these with these other predators is because of the coyotes size.  But that doesn’t mean they won’t take an advantage of an opportunity if it presents itself.

Once while kayaking on a medium-sized stream I  had a pack of coyotes follow me along the bank for several hundred yards.  I think they were just curious, but I wasn’t going to get close enough to find out.  Coyotes can be fearless when food is at stake.  Another time I watched two coyotes harass a grizzly bear off its kill and literally chase him away, nipping at his heel as he ran.  Then they went back to eat what was left of the elk calf the bear had killed.

As far as I know this is the first verifiable case where coyotes (as opposed to wolves or dogs), have killed an adult human.  There are several incidents where coyotes have attacked children and adults. In one case a child was killed. In this case, singer-songwriter Taylor Mitchell was hiking solo in Cape Breton Highlands National Park in Nova Scotia when she was attacked, dying of her wounds in a hospital.   According to this AP report, police officers summoned to the scene by other hikers shot and wounded one of at least two coyotes that were observed.

A bear that had been trained to ice skate as part of a Russian circus has attacked and killed a circus director, while wearing skates.  These types of attacks are sad, for the humans as well as the bears (this one was shot and killed).  And they are not particularly rare, given the relatively small number of people who have trained animals.  We regularly see videos and photos of people who have trained large carnivores, and consider them safe.  They are not.

Not having anything else handy, this women threw her I-Phone at a bear that was following her.  The phone distracted the bear and it stopped following her.  Ruined her I-Phone though.